Home Canadian Soccer The Association Round one to the CSA: Human Rights Tribunal co-chair won’t rush the turfgate case

Round one to the CSA: Human Rights Tribunal co-chair won’t rush the turfgate case


The Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario has rejected a plea to expedite its hearing of the grass vs. turf case.

A group of women’s players, including Americans Alex Morgan and Abby Wambach, Germany’s Nadine Angerer and Japan’s Yuki Ogimi had petitioned the HRTO to hear their plea against the use of artificial turf fields at the 2015 Women’s World Cup. The Canadian Soccer Association and FIFA have defended the use of the artificial-turf fields, while the women’s players named in the suit (a total of 15 on the document) wanted to speed the case forward in hopes of getting a ruling in favour of grass in time for it to have an impact on the WWC.

The CSA’s lawyers have stated that they doesn’t feel the HRTO has the jurisdiction to rule on a Women’s World Cup, as five of the six venues being used in the tournament are located outside of the province of Ontario.

On Friday, HRTO co-chair Jo-Anne Pickel rejected the players’ plea to expedite the case, basically killing any chance to have it heard in time to have a meaningful impact on the WWC.

She wrote that, as expedited cases put all other matters before the HRTO on the back burner, it would be unfair to all the other applicants. It would be unfair of the HRTO to delay other cases of racial, workplace and/or gender discrimination to accommodate the players.

And, Pickel said it would be even harder to expedite the case, when the players themselves waited till 2014 to file, even though the World Cup was awarded to Canada in 2011 — and it was common knowledge turf would be used.

“Another key factor weighing against the applicants’ request is their failure to proceed expeditiously in filing their application once they became aware of the alleged breach of the Code,” Pickel wrote.

Basically — if you take your sweet time to bring it to the tribunal, why should the tribunal then rush itself for you?

“As significant as this case may be for the applicants, I do not find it appropriate to expedite an application where the applicants have not themselves acted expeditiously. I do not find it appropriate to expedite an application where the applicants did not file their application until 18 months or more after they reasonably would have been aware of the fact that gave rise to the application.”

Pickel has now given the CSA and the applicants seven days to confirm or deny that they want to go into an early mediation process. According to Pickel’s paperwork, the CSA and the applicants agreed to take part in mediation. Now, the question is, would they take part in early mediation? (These look to be two separate things).

The applicants have applied for an “interim remedy” – think of it as an injunction — and the HRTO says it will rule on that in the coming weeks.


Load More Related Articles
Load More By Steven Sandor
Load More In The Association


  1. James

    November 18, 2014 at 12:03 pm

    This has stopped being a joke and is now disgraceful. The US Soccer Federation should be so ashamed of these women. A human rights issue? With all that goes on in the world? These divas need a serious history lesson.

  2. Seathanaich

    November 10, 2014 at 7:43 pm

    Don’t punish the CSA and the Canadian team for the bullsh*t engaged in my Abby Wombat and her little band of whining princesses.

  3. Mike

    November 10, 2014 at 5:25 pm

    Human rights issue? Really? Geez Louise have a place ready in the human rights museum asap. IMO if you don’t like it that bad don’t participate. So not buying a ticket to this WWC.

  4. Seathanaich

    November 8, 2014 at 3:07 am

    Unfortunately, these foreign harpies are wasting the money of our CSA, and there is nothing that can be done to force them to pay the legal costs. With this ruling, the CSA should spend as little money and time on this as they can get away with, and once the “drop-dead” point for the case has passed, they shouldn’t even bother wasting their money defending it, and let FIFA do so.

Check Also

Zero is my hero: Despite being shut out in two of three matches, Canada takes third at Algarve Cup

To finish third at a tournament, in which more than three teams were participating, withou…